A review is a scientific and methodological analysis of an existing report. It checks the validity of the path from objects and methods to findings, rather than whether another answer would be preferable.
Main checkpoints
- whether the provider's competence is sufficient;
- whether the objects actually examined match those listed;
- completeness of context and the absence of selective quotation of frames;
- scientifically defined criteria;
- the absence of legal conclusions presented as specialist knowledge;
- the logical connection between the examination and answers to the questions.
Practical outcome
A specialist opinion resulting from a review may be used to prepare questions for examination of the expert and substantiate a motion for an additional or repeat examination. The court assesses its evidential weight.
Need an assessment of a particular report?
Initially, send the appointment decision, questions or text of the report without disputed media files.
Describe your task