Objects

Photographs, video recordings, website pages, social media publications, advertising materials, film excerpts, screenshots and sequences of images.

Why the source matters

A screenshot may omit the page address, date, order of elements, caption and publication context. For analysis, it is helpful to provide a capture record, source file or information about how it was obtained, as well as the screen image.

Distinct areas of expertise

A cultural studies specialist describes content and context. Questions of editing, file age, authorship of a recording, the device used to create it or recovery of deleted data belong to technical examinations.

How to identify a disputed passage and preserve its context

Where there are many files, it is helpful to create a materials map. Each object is given a stable identifier, which is then used in the list of questions, description of the examination and appendices. For video, state the start and end of the interval under discussion; for an image, the filename and position in the set; for a page, the address and date saved.

The map helps prevent participants from discussing similar but different versions of a video. It is useful to identify the complete file, shortened publication, frames taken from it and transcript separately. If a version has different captions, an audio track or episode order, it is described as a separate item supplied.

What to include when identifying a passage

  • A brief description of the statement or characteristic that raises a question.
  • Context before and after the selected episode, without rearranging it yourself.
  • The headline, caption and available publication description, where relevant to the task.
  • Information about unavailable elements: audio, the original sequence, part of the text or page context.

It is useful to refine the question of how to interpret a frame: what function does it serve in the material supplied, and which elements of the whole support the interpretation? This links the finding to observable features and enables another specialist to locate the same episode.

A list of materials and task description are sufficient for an initial enquiry. The disputed materials themselves are submitted through agreed arrangements; access to files unrelated to the examination is not needed for this map.