Subject of examination
A forensic cultural studies examination is carried out on the basis of a court order or decision of an authorised body. Within the questions posed, the expert examines the object's cultural characteristics, content, genre, visual language, function and context.
What is supplied
- the procedural document appointing the examination;
- objects in the form in which they were entered into the case file;
- information about the source, publication and sequence of materials;
- case materials needed to understand the context.
Limits
The expert does not decide the elements of an offence, guilt, admissibility of evidence or legal classification. If personality, age, editing or psychological impact needs examination, the question of a combined examination is raised.
How to check the reasoning behind a cultural studies finding
A verifiable examination makes it possible to trace several distinct steps: what was observed in the object, how it was described and why the combination of features was assigned a particular cultural meaning. It is useful to distinguish these levels both when preparing questions and when reading a completed report.
From description to interpretation
First, the components of the material are recorded: text, visual sequence, sound, composition, order of episodes and accompanying elements. The analysis then explains which of these are significant for the question posed. A genre label or individual term must be connected to specific observations rather than used instead of an examination.
If an image permits different readings, the context that allows them to be distinguished must be considered. For example, a quotation may be reproduced for criticism, and an episode may form part of a documentary or artistic narrative. The mere possibility of such an explanation does not substantiate it: the report shows which features support the selected interpretation and which information contradicts it.
Questions for a substantive review
- Which features of each object examined were used to answer the question?
- Has the distinction between an individual frame and the complete work been preserved?
- Has the significance of the caption, sound and sequence of episodes been explained?
- Which alternative interpretations were considered, and on what grounds were they assessed?
- Do missing parts of the material affect the certainty of the finding?
In a review, this sequence helps formulate specific comments: identifying the object, page of analysis, omitted circumstance and its possible effect on the answer. Disagreement with the final wording alone does not show at which stage of the examination a problem arose.